printer friendly version

After manager Herbert Chapman led Leeds City to a fourth place finish in the spring of 1914, there were genuine hopes it would be a prelude to even better things, but the 1914/15 season ushered in no golden dawn: each of the opening four League games ended in defeat and the sixteen fixtures played by the middle of December had yielded just four victories. That depressing record left the Citizens firmly rooted in the bottom four of the Second Division and in danger of having to apply for re-election for the second time in three years. It was a sad fall from grace.

However, the visit of Leicester Fosse to Elland Road on 12 December brought clear prospects of success. The East Midlanders were in an even deeper trough than their hosts: two places below them in the table, they had already suffered ten defeats and were without a victory since the first week of November. On the 14th of that month they plumbed new depths by conceding seven goals at Wolves.

The week before they faced Fosse, Leeds had shown enough backbone, away to Nottingham Forest, to hint that they retained the underpinning zest and ability of the previous campaign. Despite going down by three goals to one, they had been the better side for lengthy periods of the match. Yorkist reported for the Leeds Mercury, "If they had exhibited a little more dash and fire in the second half they would have won comfortably."

The only change in the City eleven that turned out against Leicester was an enforced one, with Arthur Price recalled at inside-left for Jimmy Speirs, ruled out of contention shortly before kick off by an injury.

24-year-old Geordie Tony Hogg was established as first choice goalkeeper after Irish international Billy Scott returned to Merseyside to join Liverpool at the end of the previous season; Jack McQuillan, newly signed from Hull City, had started the campaign as first choice left-back, but injury cost him his place and the burly Scot, George Affleck, was recalled to partner Fred Blackman in defence. George Law, John Hampson and Mick Foley were an almost omnipresent half-back line, while Herbert Chapman had settled for Simpson Bainbridge, John Jackson, Billy McLeod, Speirs and Ivan Sharpe as his combination of choice up front.

Price, whom Chapman had signed from Worksop Town in December 1912, scored on his City debut, at home to Fulham that month, and managed three goals in twelve games that first season. He was a regular throughout the 1913/14 campaign and retained his place for the first four games of the current season; the team's form had been shabby, however, and when Billy McLeod recovered from illness and Ernie Goodwin broke into the side on the left wing, Price was consigned to City's Midland League side. The game against Leicester represented a welcome opportunity for the 28-year-old Sheffield-born inside-forward to stake a claim for a permanent first team berth. He seized the opportunity with both hands.

Fosse also made a number of changes with Teddy King, normally a right-half, leading the line, and Norman Whitfield coming in at inside-left as replacement for regular selection George Hastie.

The match was staged in wretched conditions at a windswept and rain-soaked Elland Road on a dismal winter afternoon. The crowd barely touched 5,000, City's lowest gate thus far in the campaign.

back to top

Attendances had been poor all season, with many people vehemently opposed to the continuation of competitive football while War raged in Europe. There were opposing views, as reported by the Yorkshire Post at the beginning of September: "The question of whether football should be abandoned during the War is being much debated in sporting circles, and opinion appears to be divided on the matter. While many people think it would be a disgrace to this country to have thousands of able bodied players devoting themselves to the game, and hundreds of thousands of men watching them, when there is an urgent need for volunteers, others declare that, like other amusements, football will provide a much needed release for the large numbers who must be left at home and serve to divert their attention."

Passionately championing the view that the country's priority was manning the trenches rather than the football enclosure, Colonel C F Grantham, commander of the so called Footballers' Battalion, sprang an unpleasant surprise on delegates at a special meeting of League clubs in London when he read aloud a letter which severely indicted the attitude of professional players: "You are aware that some little time ago there was much controversy in the papers with regard to the manner in which the professional football player had failed in his duty by not coming forward to serve his country in its time of stress. The laxity of the football professionals and their following amounted to almost a public scandal. Mr Joynson Hicks MP, therefore raised the Football Battalion and public opinion died down under the belief that most, if not all, of the available professionals had joined the battalion.

"This is not the case, as only 122 professionals have joined.

"I understand that there are 40 League clubs, and 20 in the Southern League, with an average of some 30 players fit to join the colours - namely 1,800. These figures speak for themselves. I am also aware, and have proof that in many cases directors and managers of clubs have not only given no assistance in getting these men to join, but have done their best by their actions to prevent it.

"I am taking the opportunity of your meeting on Monday to ask you gentlemen if you and your clubs have done everything in your power to point out to the men what their duty is. Your King and Country call upon every man who is capable of bearing arms to come forward; and upon those who are unable to use their best endeavours to see that those that can do so.

"It is no use mincing words. If men who are fit and capable of doing so will not join, they, and also those who try by their words and actions to prevent them, will have to face the opinion of their fellow men publicly.

"I will no longer be a party to shielding the want of patriotism of these men by allowing the public to think they have joined the Football Battalion."

Among the players numbered among Grantham's ranks were former City skipper Evelyn Lintott and future Leeds United manager, Frank Buckley, then a centre-half at Bradford City, both England internationals.

The Yorkshire Post: "Respecting the Association League order for the reduction of players' wages, the Leeds City players have accepted the reduced scale, but they have declined to sign the new engagement forms ordered by the Management Committee of the League. Their object in adopting this attitude is to protect against the compulsory deduction. In their opinion, the amount deducted should be regarded as a voluntary contribution towards the wages of players in less fortunate clubs. Their refusal to sign the new agreement has been reported to the Management Committee of the League."

Yorkist concluded in the Mercury, "There is not the least doubt that the football authorities decided wisely by ordering the season's programme to be started as arranged. The populace must have something to distract their minds from the great crisis, and there can be no denying that football arouses more interest than any other sport during the winter months.

"There is an impression abroad that football will not go on for many weeks; that pressure will be brought to bear on the Football Association and the Football League authorities to discontinue the game until the present crisis is less acute. If it could be proved that the continuance of football will affect recruiting to any great extent, there is not a single person but would agree to the game being temporarily stopped. My own view is that the discontinuance of football will not help recruiting much, but will only add more to the general depression caused by the War.

"His Majesty has expressed the view that racing should be continued as far as possible, and there is very little doubt that the King will also be in favour of the continuance of football. Why should racing go on and football be stopped?

back to top

"We may assume that those people who are clamouring for the stopping of all kinds of sport would also have our theatres, music halls and other places of entertainment closed. They seem to forget that there are hundreds of thousands of people who must stay at home to carry on the ordinary business of the country. Surely everything in reason should be done to relieve the depression the War is creating everywhere."

In the week that Leeds hosted Leicester Fosse, the debate raged on. Representatives of the four home Football Associations met to discuss a suggestion by Scotland that international matches should be abandoned for the season. The Scots also wanted Cup competitions to be cancelled, but that was a step too far for the others, who concluded that "there is no evidence in fact that the playing of football has hindered, or is hindering recruiting. On the contrary, there is good reason to conclude that football has encouraged and assisted recruiting… Further, the meeting is of the opinion that to deprive the working people of our country of their Saturday afternoon recreation would be very unfair and very mischievous."

There was a major schism between the Scots and the other three associations and it took some time for the scars to heal.

A conflict that many in the summer had boldly predicted would be over within a matter of weeks was proving stubbornly resistant to all attempts to bring it to a swift conclusion. On the day Leeds played Leicester, the national newspapers reported on determined attacks by the Germans on the Allied positions near Ypres in Belgium, advances by the French in Alsace, fierce fighting in Poland and the sinking of the German cruiser Friedrich Karl in the Baltic.

The opposing viewpoints were every bit as heated in Leeds as in the rest of the country and there was little surprise on a grey December day that the West Riding public should be less than enthused by the attraction of a grim re-election battle with Leicester.

City won the toss and chose to play with a strong wind in the first half. It was clear from the way they began the game that the Peacocks were determined to secure a conclusive victory and they set about the visitors with great vigour. They were rewarded for their aggression with the opening goal, registered ten minutes into the engagement.

Ivan Sharpe, the England amateur, now restored to his favourite role on the left wing after a number of outings on the opposite flank, got the better of Fosse right-back Billy Troughear and reached the byline before firing in a testing cross. The incisive ball left the Fosse ranks in a state of confusion and sparked an untidy scrimmage in the Leicester area. Young City outside-right Simpson Bainbridge had intelligently backed up the movement and he was quickest to react to the opportunity, driving a shot past goalkeeper Barnett to give his team the lead.

City did not retain their advantage for long and inside-right Billy Mills brought Leicester back onto terms with a long range effort after a miskick by Peacocks full-back George Affleck. It was a somewhat lucky score which Tony Hogg may well have saved had he not slipped as he strove to get to the shot.

The goal did little to blunt Leeds' confidence and momentum, and they were quick to press Fosse onto the back foot, swiftly restoring their lead. Bainbridge was again the beneficiary, with McLeod the provider this time, and the right winger coolly converted the centre-forward's cross to notch his second goal.

Bainbridge returned the compliment shortly before half time, sending over a centre which McLeod finished with some assurance, sending Leeds in at the break with a 3-1 lead and in control of the contest.

The goals had bolstered the home men's brittle confidence and they continued in the same vein after the break, outclassing their opponents and forcing them onto almost constant defence. The Fosse were not comfortable in their work and rarely looked capable of denying City when they seriously threatened.

Leicester were hampered badly in the second half: Whitfield had to retire with half an hour to go by virtue of a badly bruised shin while right-back Troughear went off late in the game. Long before these mishaps Leeds' stranglehold on the game was established, though while numbers were equal Leicester fought hard to remain in touch.

It was only a matter of time before City increased their advantage and Arthur Price took it upon himself to finish off the visitors almost single handed in the second half. He helped himself to a breathtaking hat trick, his first for the club after managing braces on a couple of occasions in his two years at Elland Road.

back to top

For a period in that second half it seemed that everything the inside-forward touched turned to gold and he was here, there and everywhere as his colleagues saw to it that he had a steady stream of possession. Fosse could find no solutions to the problems created by his intelligent probing.

The first of Price's trio came from an unselfish pass by McLeod; the centre-forward repeated the service for Price's second and his hat trick came after a telling cross by Bainbridge. It was an astonishing return to form in a somewhat lacklustre season for the inside-forward, who was leading the Fosse rearguard a merry dance with his incisive runs and clever footwork.

With the Peacocks now five goals to the good, it was understandable that some of their urgency was diminished. Leicester managed to pull a goal back following some good interplay between Mills and right winger George Douglas. The latter took the honours with a long dipping effort launched goalwards from the touchline. Hogg got nowhere near saving the shot, which came as something of a shock after all the one way traffic.

There was sufficient time remaining for City to add a seventh score, providing the sheen their superiority merited. McLeod got the reward for a hard working display, grabbing his second goal after a pacy run and accurate centre by Sharpe.

High scores were a feature of games between the clubs: in January 1906 Fosse had triumphed 4-1 at Elland Road and in December 1908 had won 6-2 on their own enclosure. February 1913 saw Leeds pull of a 5-1 victory on home soil, with Price helping himself to two of the goals. The scores were reversed at Filbert Street a year later and on 17 April 1915 the East Midlanders repeated that 5-1 victory when the Peacocks travelled to Leicester.

The local Press were unstinting in their praise for the way that the Citizens had recovered their glittering form of the previous campaign.

The Yorkshire Post: "There had been for several weeks much feebleness in the scoring attempts of the Leeds City forwards. But the necessity either for a special effort at improvement, or for a drastic revision in the constitution of the team, had become obvious. It is satisfactory, therefore, to find that the players have restored confidence in their abilities - and perhaps have renewed their own confidence in themselves - by the way in which they forced goals against Leicester Fosse.

"A week ago attention had to be drawn to the absence of success in organised attacks by the City forwards. It is therefore satisfactory to be able to note that the seven goals in Saturday's match were all the direct result of what may be called frontal attacks. The energy and good judgement of McLeod meant much to the forward line, and the Leeds centre can be congratulated on having reproduced the form which caused him to be placed in the running for international honours last season.

"Excepting that Jackson persistently hung on to the ball too long, all the Leeds forwards played well, and there was a good level of merit to the other branches of the team."

JRB in the Leeds Mercury: "Considering the heavy state of the ground, the game was as good as one could expect, but the home players adapted themselves to the conditions far better than their opponents. Their lusty kicking often carried them into the vicinity of the Leicester goal, where the forwards missed very few chances. The shooting of the home vanguard was admirable and Barnett had more than one difficult shot to negotiate.

"All the City goals were the outcome of cool and clever forward play, and it has been many a day since the City players scored so prolifically, or shot so often as they did on Saturday. The passing of the forwards was also good, while the wing men, Bainbridge and Sharpe, made some very speedy runs. The inside-forwards also played a capital game with the exception of Jackson, who was not so quick on the ball as McLeod and Price, the latter being a fine opportunist.

"The half-backs supported the forwards well, in addition to playing a good game on the defence. The Leicester forwards were a mediocre lot, the best of the five being Mills, although King was a hard worker. The halves, too, played a very moderate game, while the backs were seldom reliable. Barnett had a busy afternoon in goal, and he had very little chance with the shots that beat him."

After such a dismal opening half to their season, the easy victory provided a tremendous fillip for City; Arthur Price's second half opportunism and the all round combination work of the forward line revived hopes of better things to come in the West Riding. It was all the more galling, then, that the Peacocks failed to build on the display, losing 2-1 at Barnsley the following Saturday. A season of rumbling inconsistency teetered on as Herbert Chapman sought in vain to drag his men away from the wrong end of the table while the guns thundered on in central Europe.

back to top