Contact Me - What's New on the site - Leeds United news

Season 2012/13 Part 2
Brave new dawn

Luciano Becchio celebrates one of his goals against Middlesbrough on 22 December - he was now the club's talisman Part 1 Take Over My A*** - Results, table and transfers

GFH's takeover complete, it was back to football business for Leeds. Victory over Middlesbrough on 22 December took them eighth in the table and hopeful that a splurge in the transfer window would spark a genuine promotion push.

Warnock tried to temper the enthusiasm and hyperbole, denying via Yorkshire Radio that he would be 'spending stupid money for the sake of it'. He would try and get the right two or three players in, 'wheeling and dealing, because that is what I have done all my career'. He said that he would never spend £5 million on a player and just wanted support for the type of player he sought. He had targeted a certain number of players but would not confirm the details.

Ryan Hall and Michael Tonge made their moves to Elland Road permanent, Alan Tate extended his loan from Swansea, El-Hadji Diouf signed a new contract, and Everton midfield starlet Ross Barkley arrived on a month's loan. Warnock had hoped to sign West Brom striker Chris Wood, but, to the surprise of many, he was unable to match Leicester City's £1.25 million bid. On the other hand, he was delighted when United resisted all approaches for 19-year-old starlet Sam Byram, who had become a fixture in the side after being blooded at the start of the season.

Warnock met chief executive Shaun Harvey to re-evaluate the transfer strategy after reaching dead ends with approaches for several potential signings.

As a priority, Warnock was after a striker, but it was a difficult market, 'a nightmare for managers'. The players he wanted were simply not on offer. He talked of a 'domino effect', with potential sellers wanting a replacement before being willing to deal.

He was bullish at the start of the month, saying nobody would leave that he wanted to keep, although he expected enquiries for Becchio. However, there would be no one leaving unless he agreed to it because he needed every good player.

In the cold light of January, however, Warnock's hopes of retaining Becchio were dashed.

The Argentine, well into his fifth year with United, was under contract until the summer of 2014. His 15 league goals made him Leeds' top scorer by a country mile and he had emerged from the Christmas period as the club's tenth highest league goalscorer of all time.

His eye for the half-chance had brought him many admirers and Warnock feared that, despite the presence of GFH, the January window would see a repeat of previous seasons when the club's crown jewels had been tempted away from Elland Road.

A number of those moves came after contracts had been allowed to run down, but the tendency now was for United to capitalise while they could still demand a fee.

Becchio had professed his commitment to Elland Road as recently as December, but incessant talk of a transfer had turned his head.

On 24 January, the club confirmed that the club's highest earner, at around £15,000 per week, had been the subject of two separate bids from foreign clubs. He submitted a transfer request 'as financially he believes his best interests are served by a move away from Leeds United'.

back to top

The move came at the very end of the window, with Becchio joining the growing number of former colleagues at Norwich. Steve Morison made the reverse journey as part of the deal with payment of £200,000 making up the balance. The swap was not a successSteve Morisin poses wityh Neil Warnock after arriving as part of the Becchio deal for either man, each having a disastrous time with their new club.

Warnock provided the obligatory talking up, insisting that even before Becchio had asked for a transfer he had enquired about the availability of Morison, who had been top of his want list. 'Steve meets all the requirements of the striker we've been looking to bring in. For me, he is a player who has everything. He can score goals from anywhere, whether it's 25 yards or a tap-in, he has pace, and he has all the attributes you want.'

After Morison opened his scoring account for United, in his third game against Blackpool, the manager went even further, saying he would be 'a legend here in a few years' and that the fans would love him to bits. That declaration would come back to bite the manager.

Leeds also recruited former Liverpool left-back Stephen Warnock and the exotically named loanee Habib Habibou, who barely ever played for the club, but featured in an online video hurling a duck over a fence!

Shorn of Becchio's goal threat, the club's form dipped badly: they won five of the six Championship matches leading up to the Middlesbrough victory, but then won just two of the next eight.

The visit to Barnsley on 12 January was a watershed.

United went into the game on the back of three successive away defeats. They had done well at Huddersfield on 1 December when a Becchio brace inspired a 4-2 victory, but that was the only win on their travels since the end of September.

There was little enthusiasm about the trip; Oakwell had become a bogey ground for Leeds with no victories since 1997 and nine goals had been conceded in their last two visits.

There were groans of despair when Warnock announced his selection. Why was the limited David Norris in with Ross McCormack kicking his heels on the bench? Had Colin completely lost the plot?

But the fans were used to this by now, they had been ground down by results and performances and patience with the manager's pedestrian thinking was wearing very thin.

It quickly became apparent that bottom club Barnsley, under the leadership of caretaker manager David Flitcroft, were up for the game in a way that Leeds simply were not. Much as they seemed to do every year against Leeds, they belied their form, three successive league defeats, five league wins all season, the poorest scoring average in the Championship. One struggled to identify which team was at the bottom.

The mood grew darker as the game drew towards half-time, the fans sliding into a slough of despond. The first few chants of 'Warnock, Warnock, time to go' began to sound on the half hour and they grew in intensity as the players trooped off at the break.

They prayed for better in the second half, but Chris Dagnall scored twice just after the hour and despondency changed into boiling anger.

They all joined in the 'Warnock out' and 'Time to go' chants that became incessant as the game petered out, El-Hadji Diouf in action in the watershed defeat at Barnsley 12 January 2013Leeds never in it.

Even in despair, the fans, at least, were united.

back to top

Rob Atkinson penned an obituary for the Huffington Post.

'It's not safe to identify any one day, defeat or disappointment as the nadir of Leeds United's fortunes just now. At the moment, takeover and fresh start notwithstanding, they appear to be plummeting downhill faster than a greased pig.

'Today's news that top scorer Luciano Becchio has submitted a transfer request is another notable low point…Yet, you somehow have that uncomfortable, chill feeling…however bad things may seem, there's plenty of scope for them to get worse.

'Indeed, it's arguable that things have been worse…The run-up to the 2007/08 season, the club's first in the third tier of English football, was catastrophic…But that season turned into a triumph of sorts.

'At present, in some superficial measures, things might seem better - but in the most fundamental ways, they are significantly worse. Obviously, the club now enjoys a higher status within the game - the dark days of League One football are receding into the past, at least for the time being. There have been high spots too, famous cup victories and the odd satisfying away performance. At Elland Road, once a fortress notorious for intimidating opponents, form has been patchy. And yet Premier League teams have been put to the sword, and generally speaking the team will give anyone a game on their own patch. The underlying problem today, though, is more insidious than the acute emergencies immediately post-administration. It is the creeping cancer of apathy that pervades the club now.

'It's not difficult to see the signs of this. Read any of the fans' forums, and a pattern swiftly emerges. The supporters, by and large, are sick of the way the club has been run over the past few years. Sick of paying top dollar for a distinctly second-rate product. Sick of the club's habitual prevarications over transfer policy, of seeing our best players form a procession out of the exit door, sick to death of seeing lesser clubs easily out-match us for wages and transfer fees, despite the fact that our turnover and potential remain at the top end.

'Leeds United, a great name in English football by any measure, appears to have been run on the cheap for a long time now. Investment is minimal, the ability to retain promising players practically non-existent. The supporters' expectations, born of great days in the past, remain high - and why shouldn't they be? But those expectations show no sign of being met, nor even approached. Last summer's long, drawn-out agony of a takeover saga descended too often to the depths of farce, as rumour countered rumour, and we all rode an internet-driven rollercoaster of optimism and despair, over and over again. But once concluded, that saga has not spawned a legacy of more investment and better club/fan relations. We appear to be stuck with more of the same; the changes appear to have been purely cosmetic.

'On Saturday 12 January, Leeds United played Barnsley away, a fixture that had produced humiliating three-goal thrashings in the previous two seasons. This time around, it was only a two-goal thrashing, but the manner of defeat - the abject failure to muster any real threat up front, and the spectacle of midfield players gazing skywards as the ball whistled to and fro far above them - was too much for the long-suffering band of away fans in Leeds United colours. They complained, loudly. They advised the manager to be on his way. They questioned the fitness of the players to wear the famous shirt. The supporters feel they are being taken for mugs, and they have had enough.

'All this has been true for a while - but for much of the past year, change has been in the air, and it has seemed reasonable to expect that things might be about to get better. Some of us dared to dream. But after the final whistle at Barnsley's Oakwell ground, it seemed all of a sudden quite clear that the options for change had been exhausted, and that the future remains as bleak as it has been at any time since top-flight status was relinquished nine long years ago.

'It may well be that, on that cold day in Barnsley, realisation dawned that the club Leeds United once were is now dead and gone. What isNeil Warnock shouting the odds during the drab goalless draw at Blackburn 23 February left behind may well still be worth supporting, but it is likely to be a pale shadow of what we once knew. Yesterday, there were rumours of high-profile signings - and you knew, you just KNEW, that we were being softened up for more bad news. Today, it seems that Becchio is off, and we hear reports that recent loanees didn't want to stay because of the money situation up there. It all stinks of a club rotten to the core, and dead at the top.

'Leeds United - one of the truly great names in English football. RIP.'

Warnock was in utter denial after the game, blanking the abuse and saying, 'You can't blame the fans...they pay their money. But I think I'm doing a great job if I'm honest and with one or two additions that I've got lined up...I understand their disappointment, but we know we need to strengthen.'

He did acknowledge the one-sidedness of the Barnsley game, however. 'We were never at the races and they were up for it with it being a derby game. We were non-existent in midfield in the first half. I thought we started the second half okay. We made a couple of changes and we had a few chances, something we didn't have in the first half. They should have been out of sight in the first half. They were more up for it and we were being caught and were sloppy in midfield. We owed a lot to the defence who kept us in it. We were well beaten in the end.'

Falling behind to Birmingham in an FA Cup replay looked like another nail in the managerial coffin, but a second half revival secured a glamorous fourth round tie with Tottenham.

United performed superbly against Spurs, with McCormack's exquisite effort earning a famous and well-deserved 2-1 victory to add to recent knock-out successes against glamour sides. But their run then went to pot as they were walloped 4-0 at Manchester City in the fifth round.

Gifted teenager Chris Dawson enjoyed an impressive and long-awaited debut on 1 April at home to Derby, but United lost 2-1. It was the sixth game without a victory and Leeds had only won three times in the 15 Championship games since New Year's Day. It was the final straw.

Warnock recognised the writing was on the wall, telling Yorkshire Radio: 'I think it is right for the club [if I go] now.'

back to top

The club took him at his word, with development squad manager Neil Redfearn placed in temporary charge until a permanent replacement could be found.

While United were well above the relegation zone with six games remaining, they were only five points clear of the four clubs covering places 19 to 22. It was essential that a mid-table malaise did not degenerate into something more damaging.

Brian McDermott, who had led Reading to promotion to the Premier League a year earlier, was appointed on a three-year contract on 12 April. Signing such a well-regarded manager was a major coup for GFH Capital.

When asked whether he would be given the funds to rebuild the side, McDermott said the owners had told him that they were determined to make United a power again.

McDermott's reign began with victories against Sheffield Wednesday and Burnley. 'We're Leeds United, we're passing the ball,' sang delighted supporters, exhilarated at being rid of Warnock's despised hoofball. The upswing in mood was unmistakable and on 26 April the club announced that almost 11,000 season-tickets had been sold for the 2013/14 campaign.

United signed off with an impressive 2-1 victory at promotion-chasing Watford, ending the Hornets' chances of automatic promotion and setting themselves up for what they hoped would be a productive summer of rebuilding.

Away from the onfield limelight, GFH Capital's brave new world was proving anything but.

The financial results for the year to June 2012 revealed a major downturn; there were marked decreases in turnover and gate receipts and an operating loss of more than £3.3 million, presumably one of the reasons for the protracted takeover process. Leeds City Holdings posted an overall deficit of £536,000, despite the big money sales of Gradel and Howson, with the figure dramatically down on the previous year's £3 million surplus. GFH Capital's apprehension regarding cash flow issues was proven starkly well-founded.

Overall turnover dropped by more than £1.5 million and the issue was exacerbated by a £1.5 million rise in the paybill. Another £8.6 million had been lavished on the development of the stadium and the club could not keep pace with the cash burn rate. It was on its way to a £9.9 million loss for 2012/13.

GFH Capital stressed the importance of arresting the deteriorating relationship with supporters. One of their early moves was to sell half-season-tickets, beginning with United's game at home to Bristol City on 19 January.

The cost of tickets for an adult ranged from £255 to £329 but the move had little impact. The average attendance was 21,469 prior to the Bristol game; in the ten games thatThe arrival of Brian McDermptt as replacement for Neil Warnock brought a new optimism to the club followed, it rose by 230, the average for the season lower even than the Championship relegation season; in fact, it was the lowest seasonal average since 1988. Receipts were boosted by five Capital One Cup-ties at Elland Road, including the televised quarter-final against Chelsea. The crowd of 33,816 was United's highest in any competition since the FA Cup clash with Arsenal in January 2011.

Mindful of the scale of the cashflow issues, GFH Capital were desperately scouring around for 'strategic investors' who could offer financial support. Given the length and depth of their due diligence one would have naïvely expected such arrangements to have already been in place, but the size of the challenge caught the bank completely unawares.

back to top

On 10 February, GFH Capital claimed to have rejected an offer for a majority stake in the club from a Yorkshire consortium, said to be fronted by former Leeds United director Adam Pearson, who had made public his desire to return to football ownership, and Steve Parkin, chairman of Clipper Logistics, long known to desire a stake in the club.

GFH Capital executives admitted that they were willing to sell a 30% stake, raising fears that the club was already under pressure to secure a major cash injection. They steadfastly maintained that they had the necessary funds to take the club forward without the need for additional investors and that United would flourish even without investment. However, 'we are of the belief that building a strong consortium of strategic investors will better serve and protect and build our great club.'

In March 2013, GFH confirmed that they had begun negotiations to sell the club. In their financial statements, which included something akin to a sales prospectus, they stated that United was 'a bargain purchase'.

GFH's accounts revealed the price they had paid for the club, 'net cash' of $33 million (£22 million) and assessed the club to be worth $10 million (£7 million) over and above that sum. There were several conditional add-ons. Bates had owned 73% of the club so would have been due £16 million. He had never revealed how much he paid for Leeds, so it was not known whether he made a tax-free profit on the sale.

Patel claimed that even in purely profit-motivated terms, the finance house would do better to rebuild Leeds and win promotion to the Premier League than sell the club immediately. He said that if it sold a majority stake to a buyer without the funds capable of making Leeds successful, 'we become a minority shareholder in an investment not going anywhere'. He added: 'We do not wish to make a short-term profit to miss out on the £150 million-£200 million which could be made if the club wins promotion to the Premier League.'

At the end of March, GFH Capital sold 10% of the shares to Bahrain-based International Investment Bank for £2.5 million. As a result, IIB chief executive Aabed Al-Zeera joined the board of Leeds City Holdings Limited.

They also confirmed that a further 3.33% had been acquired by Salah Nooruddin, former IIB chief operating officer, who became chairman of the football club on 22 April 2013.

On 4 April, it was reported that Steve Parkin's bid for a majority stake was in doubt after an exclusivity agreement expired.

Parkin had not withdrawn his offer for a 51% shareholding, but it was becoming less and less likely he would go through with a takeover. Two months into negotiations, after he had agreed in principle to secure a majority stake, Parkin was thought unlikely to follow through unless he was able to secure financial support from investors in the Middle East.

His bid was originally thought to have the support of the wealthy Saudi Arabian who considered buying Leeds while GFH Capital was finalising its own deal in 2012, but his interest had faded. Parkin was in active discussion with potential backers but had yet to secure any sort of guarantee.

The club announced further changes to the board on 1 July, with Haigh appointed managing director and Harvey stepping down as chief executive, to be replaced byFormer IIB chief operating officer Salah Noorudding was nominated as chairman in April 2013 Paul Hunt, previously deputy CEO at Blackburn Rovers and commercial director at Leicester and Wigan.

12 days later, Brendale Holdings, a Dubai-based company where Haigh was serving as a director, advanced £11.3 million to the club as a means of restructuring GFH's loans. The sum was secured against United shares.

On 26 July, completely out of the blue, GFH Capital removed Bates as club pesident. It was announced that he would no longer have any role with the club, prompting celebrations from supporters who had campaigned for an end to his chairmanship.

back to top

The abrupt sacking came after Bates committed the club to a contract to fly him regularly to Leeds from his Monaco home at a cost of £500,000 over three years. He claimed that GFH were fully aware of his expenses, which had not changed throughout his eight years as chairman, that his contract confirmed they would continue to be honoured, and that he had never drawn a salary from the club.

Bates did not seek approval for the contract, arguing that he did not need to do so and claimed, 'I saved the club money, because this was a sterling contract, rather than euros, I did it in the best interests of the club.'

What an altruistic soul!

Bates was clear that he would pursue a legal remedy, protesting that GFH had agreed that he could continue to charge his usual expenses and saying that he had the opportunity to renewing the travel expense contract at a price lower than the existing deal. He checked with a solicitor who confirmed that a director had the authority to commit a club or a company. So, he went ahead and thought no more about it.

That was on 27 June. On 24 July, he received a hand-delivered letter saying that he had breached his contract and asking him for his comments.

He rang the lawyer concerned to say there was a perfectly reasonable explanation. 'Let's have a board meeting when I get back.' Then he received a second letter telling him his contract had been cancelled.

Whether or not Bates COULD take the decision was less the point than whether he SHOULD have done so without consulting his fellow directors. That distinction escaped a man for whom business ethics seemed to be an optional extra.

Part 1 Take Over My A*** - Results, table and transfers